Media Reviews  |  Awards  Guest Reviews  Submit a Review

"My husband and I were in Columbus for the weekend to Christmas shop and stumbled across your restaurant. I am on a gluten-free diet and I was so happy to be able to have so many choices. We had such a great meal on Friday that we chose to come back again Saturday night. our service and meals on both nights were great. I wish we lived closer - we would be regulars." -Anonymous

"This was a great experience from the moment we walked in the door! The host staff was professional looking while still being casual. I commented on how great they all looked. Not to mention they all had smiles on their faces - we felt very welcome!" -Kim

"My fiancé and I frequent Marcella's at Polaris on a regular basis. Been there a dozen times now and we always have a five-star experience overall! The dinner portions are giant, so I always know a to-go box is heading home with me for lunch the next day... just another bonus!" -Anonymous

"We always enjoy our visit to Marcella's. The food is always excellent with very good service. We will go back often." –Ed B.

"All four of us enjoyed the food. Everything we got was awesome. Salad, Pizza, lasagna - beers were cold - a great place! We would go back in a heart beat. We sat in the bar so the guys could watch Baseball game." –Dawn B.

"Hands down the best Italian food in Columbus!" -Cerise

“We had a large group (18) and Marcellas was wonderful in setting up 2 tables (one for the kids and one for adults). Food came promptly. Beet salad was surprisingly good as was calamari. Kids were happy, adults happy, great evening. It was a bit noisy and packed when we left. Definitely a place I'll come back to even when not at a conference.” —Keith

“Everything was absolutely delicious! From the Grapefruit basil martini to the apple, gorgonzola salad to the fettuccini that tasted like homemade noodles! This is definitely one of my new favorite restaurants and we will most definitely be back!”—Michelle

“Once again our meals and appetizers were superb!”

“We really enjoyed Marcella's Italian Kitchen. We were a party of 6 with two small children. Everything we ordered was good and the kid’s meals while kid-friendly were better quality than you typically get at other restaurants.”—Stacy

"Absolutely spectacular are mere words compared to the Marcella's experience. The decor is original, the staff is attentive yet unobtrusive and the food is phenominal. Everything is delicious and thoughtful. The wine list has a wide variety of tastes, but not too overwhelming. I loved this resturant from the moment I walked in and the food just topped off what I already felt. "
"Local food tycoon Cameron Mitchell opened this stylish Italian restaurant to raves. The small plates are fun to share, and the profiteroles dessert (basically a cream puff with gelato instead of cream) is to die for. "
"Last night we celebrated my son's birthday at Cameron Mitchell's Marcella's.  We had a delicious meal, enjoyed the atmosphere (felt like we were eating at our Nonna's house) and had a fantastic time.  What topped of the night was the complimentary dessert.  Not just the birthday cake for our son, but the complimentary dessert sampling tray they gave the rest of us "on the house."  When the very nice waiter presentato (presented) us our dessert it sure made an impression!

Not sure why we were treated to this squisito (delicious) surprise - maybe we were the 1,000th guest of the day. But it sure made us feel like VIPs.  This generous offer, and genius marketing move, lived up to Cameron Mitchell Restaurant's tag - great people delivering genuine hospitality.  They sure live their brand.

This definitely solidified another visit.  In fact, our daughter has made her birthday dinner reservation four months in advance.

Grazie (thanks) Marcella's.  You are one smart biscotto!"

"The food was amazing. The server, Mark was outstanding. A true asset to your company. He is passionate and knowledgeable about Marcella's and the Cameron Mitchell organization. It was a pleasure to dine at Marcella's and to have our dinning experience "hosted" by Mark." 
"Marcella's is great - there's nothing in Columbus quite like the atmosphere, food and drinks that you can find at Marcella's. We've become regulars. Thanks! " 
"My friends and I enjoy going to Marcella's after work for drinks. The bartenders are all great and the drinks are wonderful! Salute! "

 "Marcella's is a great gathering place for my friends because it allows us all to get something we like and share with each other. We love going there before a big night out because the portions are just right."

"I love the atmosphere at Marcella's, the energy and excitement makes it the place to be on any night. It definitely is a refreshing place to go after a long day. "